I beat Timmy Icepick but it did not give me the letter with the password at all at all. I beat him again but nothing happened. and I restarted the game and nothing seems to have changed. can someone plz help and fast this seems to be a major bug.
I have the exact same problem as well. Now I can't get past Marleybone without completing this quest. I did email technical support regarding this bug, but I haven't gotten a response yet. It's been about... a couple of days I think.
I just did this quest today too and was really confused that the quest box for "The Only One Left" was blank. There was no quest arrow and when I went back to William Pugsby the question mark above his head was gray. I tried fighting Timmy Icepick a couple times and restarted the game. Hopefully bug gets resolved soon as I'm questing with other people .