I have seen people with night walker and life banshee. i don't know who as it. please let me who has it so i can hatch with them. Craig Culwell :) :-) :D
miranda rubycloud has one but i dont know if she wants to hatch because it isnt an adult and she is low on gold i am trying to tell her to get critical gear
1st. Seraph not very useful but the rarest pet in Kensington Park 2nd. Gurtok Demon almost as hard as seraph 3rd. Flamezilla pretty hard to find the boss for that one it can be a code or drop as i heard
First of all I have 3 seraphs. second you could just get Flamezilla a prepaid pack. oh and by the way flamezilla is one of the best fire pets ever in my opinion.
Hmm... Tricky question... First of all, it is NOT a seraph, I have like 5 of those things! I'm not completely sure, but the nightmare pet (not the hatched one) is pretty rare.
The sheep is the rarest pet hands down cause only KI workers and KI friends got them. Thats the only pet i do not own. The rest where easy to get but took what almost 5 years to get them all. but if i had to choose one the spider golem was a pain to get.
who ever was asking about the life and death minotaurs there are 2 different death minotaurs one with wraith card one with minotaur card. lol and half these pets you guys are saying are far from rare no one equips them like ice bat and so fourth. Valkoor Soulrunner is the true pet master!!!!
The rarest pet is by far the pioneer dragon because you needed to be a beta tester years ago to get it. I have never let it go, it gives you a +30% blade to all spells. It is a dragon with stars on it.
Three pets I seldom see are my Death Scarab, my Shadow Beast, and my Gargoyle. I have only seen two other Gargoyles and no other Death Scarabs. But I do not get to play as much as I would like so there may be more out there. Can someone check on that
I think that the rarest pet drop in the game is the Ianthine Spectre, droped by the Gurtok Demon in the Plaza of Conquests, DS. I'm currently farming for it.
I have the Ianthine Spectre, I got it from a pack in the Crown Shop. I forget what pack it was, sorry I couldn't help out about that ..
I have like 20 seraphs so idk where people are coming from on seraph being the rare... :D I think the nightmare is the best pet because i have a friend that has it and it's AWESOME!!! I also think nightmare is the rarest because i have tried so hard to get one for like a year & I failed every attempt :o
:) :-) :D 
....but you can only get them if your death or if you hatch them but they are rare to hatch.
Three pets I seldom see are my Death Scarab, my Shadow Beast, and my Gargoyle. I have only seen two other Gargoyles and no other Death Scarabs. But I do not get to play as much as I would like so there may be more out there.
I'm currently farming for it.
..
